The Smart Investor
    Facebook Instagram
    Thursday, March 23
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn
    The Smart Investor
    • Home
    • About
      • About Us
      • Careers
    • Smart Investing
      • Getting Started
      • Investing Strategy
      • Smart Analysis
      • Smart Reads
    • Special Free Reports!
    • As Featured on BT
    • Our Services
      • Our Services
      • Subscribe now!
    • Login
    • Cart
    The Smart Investor
    Home»As Featured on BT»Just The Ticket For Stable Income
    As Featured on BT

    Just The Ticket For Stable Income

    David KuoBy David KuoNovember 9, 2019Updated:May 9, 20215 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email WhatsApp
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email WhatsApp

    Go on, admit it. We love to complain about our public transport systems wherever we might be living. Even if they are the best of breed, they are still never quite good enough. They are either too slow, too crowded, too expensive or they are never on time.

    What’s more, the bus stops, the taxi stands, or subway stations are never quite where we would like them.

    Then we have the occasional breakdown in service that really gets commuters fuming. And the fares. Why do they only ever go up and never come down, regardless of the direction of energy prices? Do these companies think that we commuters are made of money?

    Yes, public transport companies gets a lot of flak. But what would we do without them?

    What are the alternatives? We conveniently forget that infrastructure can cost a lot to build, cost an arm and a leg to run and bags of cash to maintain.

    But then, all that we ever see – or perhaps care about – might be why two 190 buses have just come and sped off in quick succession, and the next one doesn’t arrive for another eight minutes.

    A can of worms

    We tend to forget that public transport companies are no different to other businesses – they must be profitable. But some might argue whether they need to be.

    If they are truly “public”, then why should be run for profit at all. That opens a can of worms about the allocation of public-sector finances, which is something that economists can debate to their hearts’ content. Point is, any business, must be profitable to be sustainable.

    Generally, public transport companies do make profits. But the profits are not excessive. The median net income margin for 19 companies examined in this article is an unremarkable 4%. In other words, they only make $4 of bottom-line profit on every $100 of sales. Consequently, they can’t be accused of profiteering.

    So, if they aren’t making excessive profits, how do we account for their relatively high returns on equity of 11%? From an investor’s perspective, a high return can be an attractive attribute. It means that they could generate $11 of profit on every $100 that we have invested in them.

    So, if they can plough some of their cash flow back into their businesses, the money could grow at a desirable rate.

    Part of the reason for their high returns on equity can be found in their efficient use of assets. On average, they generate about $70 of revenue on every $100 of asset employed.

    Some of the highest include Singapore’s SBS Transit and the UK’s Stagecoach Group. The Go-Ahead Group generates more than a dollar of revenue for every dollar of asset employed in the business.

    Another driver of the high returns on equity is leverage. They use other people’s money rather than their own money to fund the business.

    They have on average about 50 times more in liabilities than assets, which is quite high. But the leverage can provide a powerful multiplier that, on average, has helped them double their return on equity. It compensate for their low net income margins.

    Where’s the money

    Many of these public transport operators pay dividends, though the payouts are, in general, not excessive. The median yield is just 2.4%. The payout appears to be adequately covered.

    On average, they only distribute around a-third of their profits, which means that around 60% is retained for use within the business.

    The retained profits could grow at around 11%, which would imply that public transport operators could grow their payout at 6% a year. Some have achieved that.

    These include Singapore’s ComfortDelGro (SGX: C52) that has grown its dividends at a compound rate of 6.5% over the last five years, and Hong Kong’s MTR Corporation has also been able to beat the average.

    Getting the right balance

    From an investor’s perspective, public transportation companies could be sound investments because of their stable revenues and cash flows.

    But the process of setting and adjusting public transport fares, which can be regulated, requires a delicate balance between affordability for commuters and the need to provide services that meet the demand of those same commuters.

    There is also a never-ending need to improve and provide more services to cater for increasing population.

    Whilst governments would like to provide funding for these services, it might be tough to do so in the long term. Public transportation companies will need to compete for funds with the demands from an ageing population and increasing healthcare costs.

    Unfortunately, there is no easy solution because the funding issues are almost as broad and as deep as our MRT network.

    So, the answer, perhaps, lies in looking for companies that could generate a decent return on equity, has a good track record of bottom-line profits and pays out some of those profits as dividends.

    A version of this article first appeared in The Business Times.

    None of the information in this article can be constituted as financial, investment, or other professional advice. It is only intended to provide education. Speak with a professional before making important decisions about your money, your professional life, or even your personal life. Disclosure: David Kuo does not own shares in any of the companies mentioned.

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email WhatsApp

    Related Posts

    Classroom

    The Greatest Secrets of Investing (Not Taught in Schools)

    March 17, 2023
    Preparation is the Key

    When Investing in Stocks: Prepare, Don’t Predict

    March 1, 2023
    Man in Suit on Summit

    How to Set Up Your Stocks for Success in 2023 and Beyond

    February 16, 2023
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn Telegram
    • Careers
    • Disclaimer & Privacy Policy
    • Subscription Terms of Service
    © 2023 The Smart Investor. All Rights Reserved. The Smart Investor, thesmartinvestor.com.sg, an investment education website managed by The Investing Hustle Pte Ltd (Company Reg No. 201933459Z) is not licensed or otherwise regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore, and in particular, is not licensed or regulated to carry on business in providing any financial advisory service. Accordingly, any information provided on this site is meant purely for informational and investor educational purposes and should not be relied upon as financial advice. No information is presented with the intention to induce any reader to buy, sell, or hold a particular investment product or class of investment products. Rather, the information is presented for the purpose and intentions of educating readers on matters relating to financial literacy and investor education. Accordingly, any statement of opinion on this site is wholly generic and not tailored to take into account the personal needs and unique circumstances of any reader. The Smart Investor does not recommend any particular course of action in relation to any investment product or class of investment products. Readers are encouraged to exercise their own judgment and have regard to their own personal needs and circumstances before making any investment decision, and not rely on any statement of opinion that may be found on this site.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.